Skip to main content
Up to 53% offSee the plans

Back to articles | Analysis | Stocks

Why Do Most Day Traders Lose Money?

Sahmino Research Desk | 17 November 2026 | 5 min read

University of São Paulo researchers followed all 19,646 people who began day trading Brazil's equity index futures between 2013 and 2015. Of the 1,551 who kept going for more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and more experience did not improve the result.

Related video

Watch the full video

Why do most people who buy in the morning and sell the same day end up losing money? A day trader is someone who buys an asset and sells the same amount of it on the same day, hoping to profit from a few hours of price swings. Plenty of courses and channels say you can make a living from home this way. The largest test ever run on real people gives a different answer: almost nobody can.

Who the study followed

Brazilian economists Fernando Chague, Rodrigo De-Losso and Bruno Giovannetti, in a paper titled "Day Trading for a Living?", followed everyone who day traded Brazil's equity index futures, the mini-Ibovespa contracts, for the first time between 2013 and 2015. Brazil's securities regulator, the CVM, supplied the account data, and the group came to 19,646 people. The first version appeared in 2019 in the University of São Paulo economics department's working paper series (no. 2019_47), and a later version in 2020 in the "Textos para discussão" series of the Fundação Getulio Vargas São Paulo School of Economics (no. 525).

The result, group by group

The researchers computed each person's net profit after fees and grouped people by how many days they had day traded:

Days of day tradingPeopleShare with a positive net profit
Just 1 day1,11129.8%
2 to 50 days9,97815.5%
51 to 100 days3,1008.9%
101 to 200 days2,7386.8%
201 to 300 days1,1685.4%
More than 300 days1,5513.0%

The six groups (1,111 + 9,978 + 3,100 + 2,738 + 1,168 + 1,551) add up to exactly 19,646, the number the paper reports. The table's main point: the longer people kept going, the smaller the share who made money. Of the 1,551 who day traded on more than 300 days (7.9% of everyone who started, from 1,551 ÷ 19,646), 97% lost money.

Even the winners earned little. According to the 2019 version, of those same 1,551 only 17 (1.1%, from 17 ÷ 1,551) earned more than Brazil's minimum wage of $16 a day, and only 8 (about 0.5%, from 8 ÷ 1,551) more than a bank teller's starting salary of $54 a day. The 2020 version's abstract puts that share at 0.4%. The top earner made $310 a day on average, with enormous swings: the standard deviation of his daily profit was $2,560, so one day's gain could be wiped out several times over by the next day's loss.

Why it happens

Every trade has a cost. The profit the study counted is after fees. Someone who buys and sells every day pays fees every day, and those costs eat small gains. On the Tehran Stock Exchange too, every buy and every sell carries a brokerage fee, and the seller pays a transfer tax.

Your opponent is not an ordinary person. In the 2020 version the authors write that it is virtually impossible for individuals to compete with high-frequency traders, computer systems that place orders in fractions of a second.

More practice did not help. The study found no evidence that people got better by continuing to day trade. That is why the table above gets worse as the days add up, not better.

What the study does not say

This study is about index futures in Brazil, not shares on the Tehran Stock Exchange, and the two markets have different rules. We have no published study of the same rigour on Tehran's day traders, and we do not invent a figure for Iran. What carries over from Brazil to any market is the mechanism: a fee on every trade, an opponent faster than you, and no sign of learning. Nor does the study say anything about long-term investing; its subject is only buying and selling within the same day.

Bottom line

Day trading is more like a race where you pay the entry cost up front and your opponent is faster. Before each purchase, ask yourself: how long do I want this share, and why? For common traps, read 4 Traps of Signal-Selling Channels and Four Beginner Mistakes on the Tehran Exchange, and see 5 Things Professional Investors Do With Their Money. If you trade, record your trades in your Sahmino portfolio to see your real profit after fees.

References

  1. FEA-USP Department of Economics Working Papers | University of São Paulo97% of those who persisted at least 300 days lost money; only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller (US$54 per day).Cited Nov 17, 2026
  2. FGV EESP Textos para discussão | Fundação Getulio VargasVirtually impossible for individuals to compete with HFTs and day trade for a living.Cited Nov 17, 2026
  3. QuantpediaCohort table of 19,646 new day traders and the 17 / 8 earners among 1,551 persistent traders, quoted from the paper.Cited Nov 17, 2026

Related articles